…aka Why You Shouldn’t Spend Sixty Bucks On Fable III
Let me go ahead and say that this will NOT be a spoiler-free review. If you don’t want spoilers, turn back now. You’ve been warned.
After playing Fable II and enjoying it thoroughly, I was more than willing to lay down sixty bucks for Fable III. I’d heard some shaky things about it, but I doubted it could really be that bad. How wrong I was.
I happily took my purchased game home and when the time finally came to start it, I cheerfully put the disc in the XBox and booted it up. It took maybe all of twenty minutes for the luster of it to wear off. I don’t know how they did it, but they managed to take the things that worked in Fable II and break them.
The simply explanation of the plot of the game is that you are a prince or princess and your brother is in charge of the kingdom and is messing it up royally. (Pun intended.) You end up having to flee the castle and go to work on building a revolution to take your kingdom back. You do and then find out there’s actually an even bigger threat and defeating it is the real goal of the game. The more in depth explanation of the game is about the same. There’s really not a lot to it.
Overall, the game is pretty dull. Even the characters are pretty bland. You waste a lot of time on what generally seem like pointless tasks that lack much creativity. I also found a few glitches that kept me from finishing (and even starting) a couple of the quests. The main point of the game is to run around your kingdom, trying to gain support and making promises to various groups in return for their promise to fight in the revolution. Each task that you complete earns you Guild Seals which unlock certain items on the Road to Rule. I’ll elaborate…
The Road to Rule is what was put in place in Fable III to help explain your progress and allow you to unlock more powerful spells, weapon abilities and so forth. The creepy blind woman from Fable II is back and appears on the Road to Rule as some kind of strange spirit guide. There are a few problems with the Road to Rule. The first is that you have to play a lot of side quests to earn enough seals to unlock the treasure chests containing various skills, so you have to pick and choose carefully or do just about every quest in the game. However, a lot of those chests are for things that I feel your character should be able to do from the beginning. Did we really need to unlock the ability to buy houses, to buy businesses, to have other characters fall in love with you, to earn additional character expressions, to go up levels in the mini games and dye your clothes? Are you saying my character is too stupid to be able to fall in love without wasting seals for them to learn how? Or how hard is it to go and buy a house? Did I actually unlock some kind of medieval home buyers guide?
The combat in the game is pretty easy. You have three focuses you can work with: melee, ranged and magic. Depending on which you focus on more, your character’s physical appearance will change. Melee combat makes you more muscled, ranged makes you taller and magic makes you all glowy. Attacking is really basic and there aren’t really any special moves. The best part about training your character up in any of the three options is that with a focus in melee or ranged weapons, your weapons actually evolve to look more bad ass. With magic, you are able to do a thing called spell-weaving which actually lets you combine two different magic spells together. For example: fire and electricity or ice and magic daggers.
Individual enemies in the game are pretty simple to beat, but it’s easy to get swarmed by bad guys and have your ass handed to you. This wouldn’t be so bad except that the only times I ever got knocked out were because of random swarms of baddies and not the final boss fight. How does that work? I also got tired of the non-randomized enemy encounters that seemed to happen every five feet. It wasn’t exciting, it was annoying.
Instead of tweaking the menu system from Fable II that so many complained about, they removed it entirely. This removed easy access to your inventory, stats, saving, etc. Instead they decided to give you a sanctuary that you could return to any time by pressing the “start” button. Even once you arrived there, you had to go into a separate room for you weapons, clothing/hair/makeup and money. When you access a side panel for your character’s stats, you receive a watered down status. There are no fun stats like how many chickens you’ve kicked, bad guys you’ve killed, STDs you’ve received (I’m not making this up), etc. Instead, you will see those randomly appear on your loading screens. The main room also includes a map which allows you to check in on the status of property and quests and then to teleport to different locations.
One of the other rooms in your sanctuary is basically the XBox Live room. You can locate other players and buy in-game items with your Microsoft points. That’s all very well and good, but you are constantly reminded of it when you teleport back and your butler recommends checking out the shop. I get it, you want to sell me stuff. Shut the hell up already! It was like listening to a bloody commercial on repeat. Wait, that’s exactly what it was. Infinite infomercial loop.
While it may seem nice to be able to save your game at any point by traveling to the sanctuary, it’s really not that necessary. The game auto-saves a lot, but that’s also part of the problem. If you screw up, there is no going back. Maybe the point was that the game makers wanted you to have to live with your decisions, but I found it ultimately frustrating. It also means that to see an alternate outcome to something, you’d have to start a whole new game.
Also located in your sanctuary is an area for gifts you’ve received from people in the kingdom. No more finding out what they gave you when you receive them. No, you have to go back to the sanctuary to open them.
On the subject of gifts from towns people, you can no longer win over crowds with your charm. You have to approach NPCs ONE BY ONE, waste a lot of time doing things like heroic poses or whistling to win them over and then they send you on an errand to win them over completely. (Winning them over completely is a crucial step to starting a relationship should you want to have an in-game romance.) The errands get dull and repetitive for not much return.
Starting a family in Fable III is fairly consistent with how it is in Fable II. (Even though my fair skinned child changed racial backgrounds for no apparent reason at one point.) However, there is one kink. Your children will ask you for presents, but unlike Fable II where you could go to most any shop and get a lot of similar items, stalls and stores only carry two to five items or so. So you either have to find the right stall carrying the right item or find it out in the world. One of my children got all upset because I couldn’t find the porcelain doll they asked for anywhere. It was like trying to find the hot Christmas item for kids on Christmas Eve.
So, let’s link this in to the problem with shops. It is incredibly hard to find what you want half of the time. There are items that are exclusive to each town and, as noted before, each shop has a stupidly limited amount of goods. Are you really telling me the guy at the gift vending stall only carries two things? Really?
In Fable III, they bring the money-earning mini games back. The available jobs are blacksmithing, lute playing and pie making. To play, you have to hit a sequence of buttons on your controller in time with the screen (sort of like Guitar Hero or Rock Band). As you play each section of any given mini game, your gold multiplier goes up (the amount you earn per successful sequence). The problem is that I kept running into lag on my system and it would screw me up around the sixth or seventh level multiplier. It also didn’t help that the NPCs were stupid and would walk right through my character while playing the games which ended up being distracting.
So, I’ve covered a lot of what I didn’t like about the game. What about the things I did like? Well, they were few and far between. There were a couple of quests that were fun (one is particularly entertaining if you’re a D&D player). There was a lot of quirky humour throughout, including some really awesome posters that are displayed in the cities. The game does seem to pick up a little bit in the second half, but it’s too little too late. What parts I did enjoy were pretty much washed away by the major problem with the game: it sets you up to fail.
As with the last two games in the Fable series, you are allowed to be a moral and upright character, a conniving villain or something in between. This game makes it exceptionally hard to start out playing an evil character. The whole point is that you’re supposed to gain support from various factions to aid your cause. How can you do that if you just piss them off all the time? I don’t know, maybe it doesn’t change things much to be evil, but with the auto-save system, it’s hard to give it a try and back up if necessary.
Here’s where things get screwed up. If you decide to play a moral character, the ending will screw you over. What seems like the goal of the game (winning back your kingdom and being crowned ruler) is only a part of the final story. It turns out there is an evil darkness heading your way and you need to amass enough wealth to properly afford protection for your citizens and you only have one year to do it in. As ruler, you have to make decisions that will eat into your money pile or will help build it. Keeping the promises you made along the way always eats into the funds, but choosing the more corrupt options will help you build it. So, if you’re playing a moral character you have to choose between most of the population of Albion dying or deciding to become a dick. Making unpopular decisions does more than upset your people, it also ruins your kingdom. Things like using one area as a place to dump sewage and draining a lake to mine for precious materials. Out of all of the decisions you have to make, only two or three (of maybe twelve to fifteen or so) are moral and earn you money.
The year you are allotted to try to build up your treasury counts down unevenly. You start with 365 days and once you complete the tasks for one day, you’re knocked down to 320-some days and so on. There is no knowing when you’re finally going to run out of time. This caught me off guard and prevented me from transferring personal wealth to the kingdom’s treasury. Because of this, the majority of my citizens died. After a ridiculously easy boss fight where I simply spammed the magic button, I came back to find my castle strewn with dead bodies. By doing the right thing I doomed most of Albion’s citizens to death. What kind of ending is that? If you play an asshole, then you save more people? Is it like Dark Helmet says in “Spaceballs” that “evil will always triumph because good is dumb”? I can’t recall ever being so dissatisfied with the ending of a game before.
Fable III feels unfinished, forced and unoriginal. It’s a short game, and it pales in comparison to Fable II. Sequel games should get better, not worse.
Save your money. Go by Cataclysm or, if you’re looking for another fantasy game on a PS3 or 360, get Dragon Age. I guarantee either of those options will be better than the fail that was Fable III.
-