
Unsettling Bruce Willis bot.
Thanks to Netflix and my laziness, I had time to sit down and watch Surrogates starring Bruce Willis. Surrogates is about a future world where most people stay inside, opting to live their lives through a robotic avatar (not the blue kitty kind mind you) that goes out into the world while the user pilots them remotely. Naturally, the surrogate bots tend to be everything their operator is not, and since they are robots, if they are destroyed, their owner remains safely at home…or do they?
To add some spice, someone starts killing surrogates with a device that also kills their operators. It’s the job of Willis’ character to find out the “who”, “what” and “why”. Of course, creepy youthful Willis-bot ends up biting it which forces real life, not so pretty Willis to venture out into the world as a vulnerable meatbag.
While the story was nothing all that unexpected (human protesters against surrogates, surrogate operators who want things to stay the way they are), it was fairly well executed. The twist as to who the real killer was caught me a little off guard, and I was enjoying the movie…then they blew it with the ending.
There’s not much more upsetting in a movie to me than when everything falls apart at the end. The finish for the movie felt forced and disingenuous. It was as if some studio exec said they needed to scrap whatever ending was there before in favour of something cheerier. The problem is that it went against character motivations and ends up lacking the bite they could have had with something a bit more dismal. The movie could have really driven home the social commentary it was trying to bring and still have been satisfying to the viewers. (See the spoiler section for more on the ending.)
The effects in the movie are adequate, the script was decent and the acting was enjoyable. It could have been so much more though, and after reaching the ending, all I can see is wasted potential.
Final Score: 2 out of 5.
BEYOND THIS POINT ARE SPOILERS…TURN BACK IF YOU HAVEN’T SEEN THE FILM OR CARE ABOUT CHARACTER AND PLOT POINTS BEING REVEALED…
Here is my big problem with the ending. Willis’ character decides at the very last moment, after he’s confirmed that no operators will die, to wipe out the entire surrogate population. All at once, every surrogate in the U.S. shuts off and crumples to the ground. The cleanup of the bots would be horrendous, let alone the crashed cars and any collateral damage caused by said crashing vehicles. (I wonder if airplanes would have crashed too.) However, that’s not the biggest problem. According to the movie, you have a society that has lived for several years through their surrogates. They have adjusted to doing next to nothing for themselves. To take all of that away at once would cause widespread panic. People wouldn’t know what to do with themselves anymore, and having to face their own unperfected face in the mirror day after day would likely drive some people mad. Suicide rates would probably skyrocket and the work force would be all kinds of screwy. Jobs that could once be completed by robots might be completely unmanageable for a human. You are talking about a complete infrastructure change because one guy decided to pull the plug.
The more poignant ending would have been the character protecting the life he knew. To choose to continue this distant existence through a robot. It may not have been the sappy “he and his wife are truly reunited” ending that they had, but it would have made more sense and had far more impact.
-




